How to Track Employee Hours for Small Business [2025 Guide]
Time TrackingWorkforce Management
How to Track Employee Hours for Small Business: Complete 2025 Guide
W
Workant Team
HR Software Experts
January 15, 20256 min read
Tracking employee hours accurately is one of the most critical—and often overlooked—aspects of running a small business. Get it wrong, and you face payroll errors, compliance issues, and frustrated employees. Get it right, and you'll save money, stay legal, and gain valuable insights into your labor costs.
In this guide, I'll walk you through everything you need to know about tracking employee hours for your small business, from choosing the right method to avoiding expensive mistakes.
Why Accurate Time Tracking Matters for Small Businesses
Before diving into the how, let's be clear about the why. Accurate employee time tracking directly impacts:
Payroll accuracy: The American Payroll Association estimates that the average error rate for manual time tracking is 1-8%. For a business with 20 employees earning $50,000 annually, that's $10,000-$80,000 in potential overpayment or underpayment.
Legal compliance: The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires employers to keep accurate time records. Non-compliance can result in back wages, penalties, and lawsuits—particularly for overtime violations.
Labor cost visibility: When you know exactly where employee hours go, you can identify inefficiencies, optimize scheduling, and make smarter hiring decisions.
5 Methods to Track Employee Hours (Compared)
There's no one-size-fits-all solution. The best method depends on your business type, team size, and budget. Here's an honest comparison:
1. Paper Timesheets
Best for: Very small teams (1-5 employees) with simple schedules
Cost: Free (plus your time)
Paper timesheets are the traditional approach—employees write down their start and end times, and someone manually calculates hours. While essentially free, they come with significant hidden costs:
• High error rates (transposition errors, illegible handwriting)
• Time theft is easy and undetectable
• Manual calculation takes 5-10 minutes per employee per pay period
• No real-time visibility into who's working
2. Spreadsheets (Excel/Google Sheets)
Best for: Small teams (5-15 employees) with basic needs
Cost: Free to ~$12/month for Google Workspace
A step up from paper, spreadsheets allow for formulas that automatically calculate hours and overtime. Many small businesses start here because they're familiar with the tools.
The problems: version control issues (which sheet is current?), no mobile access for field workers, and they still require manual data entry that's prone to errors.
3. Time Clock Apps (Mobile-Based)
Best for: Growing teams (10-100 employees) needing flexibility
Cost: $3-$10 per employee per month
Modern time tracking apps let employees clock in and out from their smartphones. Most include GPS verification, automatic overtime calculation, and direct payroll integration.
This is where most small businesses find the sweet spot between cost and functionality. You get accuracy and automation without enterprise-level complexity.
4. Physical Time Clocks
Best for: Single-location businesses with on-site employees
Traditional punch clocks have evolved into biometric systems using fingerprints or facial recognition. They're excellent for preventing buddy punching but limited to on-site use.
5. Integrated HR Software
Best for: Businesses that need time tracking plus scheduling, leave management, and HR features
Cost: $4-$15 per employee per month
All-in-one HR platforms combine time tracking with employee scheduling, leave management, and other HR functions. While the per-employee cost may be slightly higher, you eliminate the need for multiple disconnected systems.
How to Choose the Right Time Tracking Method
Answer these questions to narrow down your options:
Where do your employees work? If you have remote, field, or multi-location workers, you need a mobile solution. Physical time clocks won't work.
What's your budget? Calculate the true cost of your current method, including the time spent on manual data entry and error correction. Often, paid software pays for itself in saved admin hours.
Do you need overtime tracking? If you have non-exempt employees, automatic overtime calculation prevents costly compliance mistakes.
What other HR needs do you have? If you also struggle with scheduling or leave tracking, an integrated platform will serve you better than a standalone time clock app.
Common Time Tracking Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
Mistake #1: Not Having a Clear Policy
Before implementing any time tracking system, document your policies: When should employees clock in? What happens if they forget? How do you handle breaks? Clear policies prevent disputes and ensure consistent application.
Mistake #2: Ignoring Mobile Workers
If your employees work in the field, from home, or at client sites, a desktop-only or physical time clock creates friction. They'll revert to manual entry—and you'll lose accuracy.
Mistake #3: Not Integrating with Payroll
Manual transfer of time data to payroll is where most errors occur. Look for solutions that integrate directly with your payroll provider to eliminate re-keying.
Mistake #4: Over-Monitoring
While it's tempting to track every minute, excessive monitoring damages trust and morale. Focus on the data you actually need: clock in/out times, breaks, and project allocation if relevant.
Getting Started: Your Next Steps
If you're currently using paper or spreadsheets and have more than 10 employees, it's likely time to upgrade. Here's how to make the transition smooth:
1. Audit your current process: How long does time tracking and payroll prep actually take? What errors have occurred in the past year?
2. List your requirements: Mobile access? GPS? Overtime rules? Payroll integration?
3. Trial 2-3 solutions: Most time tracking software offers free trials. Test with a small group before rolling out company-wide.
4. Train your team: Even simple software needs proper introduction. Explain the why—employees are more likely to adopt tools they understand.
5. Monitor and adjust: Check in after 30 days. Are employees using it consistently? Are you seeing the expected benefits?
The Bottom Line
Tracking employee hours doesn't have to be complicated or expensive. The key is choosing a method that matches your business size, work environment, and budget—then implementing it consistently.
For most small businesses with 10+ employees, a modern time tracking app or integrated HR platform offers the best balance of accuracy, ease of use, and cost-effectiveness. The small monthly investment typically pays for itself within the first pay period through reduced errors and saved administrative time.
Ready to transform your HR?
Start your free trial today and see how Workant can streamline your HR processes.
